Alabama quarterback is one of the most electrifying athletes in the 2025 NFL Draft class. At 22 years old, his dual-threat ability makes him an intriguing prospect for teams like the New York Giants, who are searching for solutions at quarterback. However, Milroe’s potential comes with significant risks, particularly for a team in need of immediate stability.
Elite Rushing Ability, Raw Passing Talent
Milroe is a dynamic force on the ground, amassing 879 rushing yards and 20 touchdowns in 2024 while averaging nearly six yards per carry. His speed and power make him an instant threat in designed runs and read-option plays, offering a skill set few quarterbacks in this draft can match.
As a passer, however, Milroe is a work in progress. Completing 63.3% of his passes for 2,834 yards with 16 touchdowns and 11 interceptions, he’s shown flashes of promise but lacks consistency. His mechanics—relying too heavily on his arm and failing to engage his lower body—limit his accuracy and ability to throw into tight windows. These deficiencies, coupled with a tendency to force throws and drop his eyes under pressure, underscore the need for significant development.
The Giants’ Dilemma
The Giants face a challenging decision when evaluating Milroe. While his physical tools are undeniable, his inconsistency as a passer and decision-making issues are concerning for a franchise that requires stability at quarterback. His tendency to abandon the pocket prematurely could exacerbate problems for a team that struggled with wasted drives in 2024.
Milroe is not a plug-and-play solution. To succeed, he would require a tailored system emphasizing his strengths as a runner while giving him time to refine his passing mechanics. Pairing him with a veteran quarterback like Justin Fields or Russell Wilson could provide the bridge New York needs while Milroe develops.
A Candidate for Further Development
Despite declaring for the draft, Milroe may have benefited from another year in college, particularly in a pass-heavy system that could accelerate his growth. With only 187 completions in 2023 and a career-high 65.6% completion rate, his resume lacks the polish most NFL teams expect. Another collegiate season could have refined his mechanics and processing abilities, setting him up for greater success at the next level.
Betting on Upside
For the Giants, drafting Milroe would be a high-risk, high-reward move. It would signal a willingness to prioritize upside over immediate results, betting on his physical tools and the coaching staff’s ability to mold him into a complete quarterback. However, given their current needs and the importance of finding a stabilizing presence under center, the Giants may opt for a more polished prospect.
Milroe’s future success hinges on landing in the right situation—one that can provide the stability and patience required for his development. Whether the Giants are prepared to take that leap remains to be seen.
